I don't know if you have noticed or not, but I have taken a few days to witness without the little ones. Today, I gave it another shot. After dinner I loaded up Caden and Alyssa into a wagon and we all went on a walk. Mia walked beside the wagon. Together we looked for someone to invite to church. The only person that we found was the mailman.
Me: Mr. Mailman, the kids and I would like to invite you to our church this weekend. Do you have a church background?
Mailman: Yes. I go to...They are actually having a fish fry while we speak so I'm kind of in a hurry.
Me: Okay, we will let you go. Do you know how to get to heaven?
Mailman: I do. Thank you.
Me: Here is a gospel tract. Have a good evening.
Short and simple is the way to share when you have several little kids. Caden and Alyssa stayed in the wagon, without fighting, and Mia did not get hit by a passing car. That's a successful encounter as far as I'm concerned.